Comparisons
Comparisons
There is no point looking for the one right way to listen to music: different approaches solve different problems. We compare approaches, not services: what each one gives you, how it limits you and who it suits. The tables will help you see what you are paying for and what you keep if you change your mind.
A subscription is like a membership to a huge library; buying is like having your own shelf. It helps to know which of the two you need.
How to read the tables: they describe general principles. What a specific plan includes, how offline mode works and what happens after you cancel are set out in the rules of the service you choose.
Subscription vs purchase
| Criterion | Streaming subscription | Buying a digital album |
|---|---|---|
| What you get | Access to a large catalogue for as long as you pay | A file you can keep and play without any subscription |
| When the payments stop | Access to the catalogue and offline downloads ends | What you have bought stays with you |
| Pros | Huge choice, recommendations, new releases appear straight away | Not affected by changes to the catalogue or the service's terms |
| Cons | Recordings can disappear from the catalogue; charges are recurring | You pay for each album separately and look after the backup yourself |
| Who it suits | People who listen to lots of new music and love discovering the unfamiliar | People who keep returning to favourite recordings for years |
Free ad-supported tier vs paid
| Criterion | Free ad-supported tier | Paid tier |
|---|---|---|
| How it works | You can listen without paying, but with ad breaks and restrictions | A regular payment removes most of the restrictions |
| Typical restrictions | No offline mode, tracks may play in shuffled order, skips are limited | Far fewer restrictions; what exactly is unlocked is stated in the terms |
| Pros | Nothing to pay, a convenient way to try out a service | Music plays without interruptions, including without internet |
| Cons | Ad breaks and less control over what plays | A recurring charge that is easy to forget about |
| Who it suits | People who listen in the background and not very often | People who listen every day, on the move or away from a connection |
Streaming vs your own files
| Criterion | Streaming | Your own files |
|---|---|---|
| Where the music is stored | On the service's servers and, in offline mode, inside the app | On your device, an external drive or your personal storage |
| Where you can listen | Wherever the app is installed and you are signed in to your account | In any player that opens the file format |
| Pros | Nothing to store or organise by hand | Full control: tags, folders, order, backups |
| Cons | The catalogue changes and the service sets the terms | You need space, time to keep things tidy and a regular backup |
| Who it suits | People who value convenience and variety | Collectors and people who are often without a connection |
How to choose without second-guessing
Many listeners combine approaches: a subscription for discovery and background music, purchases for the albums they want to keep. That is sensible as long as you know where everything is and don't keep the only copy of your favourite recordings inside an app.
Weigh up not only the money but also the effort. Your own files need tidying and a backup; a subscription needs attention to charges and terms. Choose what will be easiest for you to keep up for years, not what looks like the better deal at the start.
Read next
- Guides
Step-by-step advice: choosing how to listen, using offline mode, cancelling a subscription without losses, tidying your library. Also our article catalogue.
- Tools
Headphones and speakers, backing up purchased files, playlists, tags, offline downloads inside a service and family sharing, in general terms.
- Problems
A track has vanished, music won't play offline, downloads have disappeared, a purchased file won't open, a video was blocked, a trial was charged.
- Glossary
Streaming, subscription, offline mode, digital purchase, licence, free licence, public domain, sound recording, playlist, tags.
- Questions
Answers about this guide, about listening to and paying for music, about using tracks in your own videos and about staying safe.
Sources
- Civil Code of the Russian Federation, Part Four (summarised in general terms)
- Descriptions of free licences (summarised in general terms)
- Editorial materials of this guide
This advice is written in general terms and reflects the editors' view on the date it was prepared. Music services often change their terms, features and the names of sections in their apps. If your service's rules or the text of a licence differ from our description, follow them.